Canada’s downtowns are in trouble, and business leaders are sounding the alarm. Crime, mental health struggles, addiction, and homelessness have created a public safety crisis that is impacting the economic heart of cities across the country. At the centre of the controversy is the growing concern over repeat offenders—criminals who are released on bail only to commit further crimes, eroding public safety and harming small businesses. The International Downtown Association Canada (IDA Canada) is calling on the federal government to reform bail laws and provide additional funding for mental health, addiction, and homelessness support.
Downtown Businesses Struggle with Crime and Safety
Representatives from IDA Canada gathered on Parliament Hill on October 8, pressing the federal government to take immediate action. Their message is simple: repeat offenders are making it nearly impossible for downtown businesses to thrive. Kate Fenske, chair of IDA Canada, highlighted a sharp rise in non-violent crime, pointing to data from the Nonviolent Crime Survey Index that shows a 10% increase in property and drug offences over the last two years, while shoplifting has surged by almost 20%. For downtown businesses, this rise in crime is more than just statistics—it’s their daily reality.
“IDA Canada is urging the federal government to help ensure our downtowns and main streets are inclusive and safe spaces for everyone by initiating a systematic review of the bail system and reforming Bill C-48 to address theft,” Fenske said during the press conference.
The current bail system, as it stands, isn’t working. Premiers across Canada have echoed the call for a thorough review of Bill C-48, a law aimed at modernizing bail procedures. Yet, according to business leaders, it has done little to stem the tide of repeat offenders who continue to wreak havoc on downtown areas. Small businesses, the lifeblood of urban centres, are particularly vulnerable to these rising crime rates, with shoplifting and property damage threatening their survival.
Bill C-48: Is It Protecting Canadians?
Bill C-48 was intended to bring improvements to Canada’s bail system, but for many, it has been a failure. The law has come under scrutiny, as critics claim it doesn’t do enough to prevent repeat offenders from committing further crimes while on bail. Fenske is among those pushing for reform. “Every single day in communities across Canada, there are stories of crime perpetrated by an individual who was on bail or breached bail conditions,” she noted.
While the federal government insists it has done its part by passing Bill C-48, it has passed the responsibility of enforcement onto the provinces, sparking frustration among municipal leaders and business associations alike. The premiers and IDA Canada are demanding a systematic review of the law’s implementation, calling for an analysis of bail data to evaluate its effectiveness.
But there’s more to this conversation than just bail reform. It’s about addressing the root causes of crime.
The Underlying Crisis
At the heart of the crime issue in Canadian cities is the broader social crisis of mental health, addictions, and homelessness. These challenges are not limited to downtown businesses—they affect entire communities. Fenske and other members of IDA Canada argue that no solution to public safety will be complete without addressing these underlying problems.
“The federal government can and should play a larger role in addressing the humanitarian crisis impacting our neighbourhoods,” Fenske said. She, along with other business leaders, is calling for additional federal funding to tackle these issues head-on.
The Liberals have been urged to dedicate resources to mental health services, addiction treatment, and homelessness support. While the provinces administer many of these services, Fenske stressed that the federal government must take a leadership role in providing the necessary funding and ensuring that it reaches the people who need it most.
The crisis is all too visible in urban centres like Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside (DTES), where addiction, homelessness, and crime have converged into a public safety nightmare. For years, governments have struggled to find a balance between compassion and enforcement in areas like the DTES, but the problems continue to worsen. If the federal government is serious about solving these issues, they need to take decisive action—and they need to do it now.
Crime, Safety, and the Future of Canadian Downtowns
Canada’s main streets and downtowns are the heart of the economy, yet they are struggling to survive in an environment of uncertainty and fear. Business leaders argue that unless immediate reforms are made, the long-term consequences could be devastating—not just for businesses, but for entire cities. Repeat offender crimes are a significant factor driving the public safety crisis, and without changes to the bail system, public confidence in law enforcement and government will continue to erode.
“Confidence in public safety is very low—this issue is too urgent to delay,” Fenske warned in a press release. And she’s not wrong. With downtowns and small businesses facing challenges that make it difficult to attract people, investment, and jobs, there’s an urgent need for action to ensure that cities can thrive once again.
Balancing Justice and Compassion
While the demand for bail reform is clear, this isn’t just about locking people up and throwing away the key. At the core of IDA Canada’s call for action is a recognition that criminal behaviour often stems from deeper societal issues. Homelessness, untreated mental illness, and addiction are driving factors behind much of the repeat offending that plagues Canadian cities. Without addressing these root causes, no amount of bail reform will fix the problem.
What’s needed is a balanced approach—one that focuses on accountability while also providing the social supports that can help people break out of the cycle of crime. The federal government must act not only to reform bail laws but to ensure that treatment programs, mental health services, and housing solutions are adequately funded.
Time for Federal Leadership
Fenske’s message was clear: downtown businesses cannot survive in a climate of unchecked crime and public safety concerns. It’s time for the federal government to step up and take the lead. Reforming Bill C-48 is just one piece of the puzzle. Comprehensive solutions are needed—solutions that include bail reform, social support for mental health and addiction services, and targeted investment in community safety initiatives.
As public safety erodes, downtown businesses are struggling to remain open, and the vibrancy of Canada’s urban centres is at risk. The federal government must not only consult with the provinces and municipalities but also deliver meaningful change that protects both businesses and citizens alike. Without it, Canadian downtowns could continue to deteriorate, unable to attract the investment, tourism, and jobs that drive economic growth.
Canada’s downtowns are calling for change, and the federal government can no longer afford to sit on the sidelines. With the stakes higher than ever, businesses and communities need concrete solutions—solutions that balance justice and compassion, law and social support. The public safety crisis won’t fix itself. It’s time for leadership and action, before more damage is done to the heart of Canada’s cities.
The debate has begun—will Ottawa rise to the challenge?
DOWNTOWNEASTSIDE.ORG is a collective author account used by several DTES contributors to discuss key issues and events in the neighbourhood. Articles under this authorship reflect diverse perspectives from those directly connected to the community. If you’d like to reach a specific contributor, please contact us via email.
Leave a Comment